Historian claims Napoleon was forerunner of Hitler


Claude Ribbe argues in a study that the emperor ordered the murder of 100,000 West Indians, using among other things sulphur dioxide gas from 1802.

Napoleon Bonaparte was “a precursor to Hitler”, according to French philosopher and historian Claude Ribbe, a native of the West Indies, who reproaches the French emperor for having had more than 100,000 people murdered.

This is the main thesis of Ribbe’s historical essay entitled “Napoleon’s Crime”, which will be published in France on 1 December and was previewed by the popular daily France Soir.

The author attributes to Napoleon the organisation, from 1802 onwards, of the genocide of more than 100,000 West Indians from Haiti and the island of Guadeloupe, the deportation of several thousand of them, and the passing of racist laws, such as the ban on mixed marriages.

The famous emperor reinstated slavery in France – which had been abolished in 1794 – not only for economic reasons but also because it was “deeply racist”, according to his version.

Napoleon did not hesitate, says Ribbe, to “get rid” of those who had rebelled against the re-establishment of slavery, and to bring a new, more docile generation of slaves from Africa to the West Indies.

These rebels, along with thousands of innocent people, were executed, drowned, eaten by dogs, and even “gassed” with sulphur dioxide, according to the historian’s thesis.

The book will come out a day before the commemoration of the bicentenary of the victory of Austerlitz, in which Napoleonic troops defeated an alliance of absolutist monarchies.

André Santini, mayor of Issy-les-Moulineaux on the outskirts of Paris and a deputy for the ruling UMP (conservative) party, wrote to French Prime Minister Dominique de Villepin on Monday to ask that the bicentenary be commemorated nationwide.

Santini, who describes himself as a “Bonapartist”, believes that in his 15-year reign, Napoleon’s contribution to France was equivalent to centuries of history.

By contrast, Victorin Lurel, a socialist MP for the Guadeloupe constituency and mayor of Vieux-Habitants on the Caribbean island, wants streets named in honour of Napoleon throughout France to be renamed, wants the country’s school textbooks to also tell of the emperor’s dark side and will take up the issue in the National Assembly next Tuesday.

“Napoleon’s Crime” adds to the more than 5,000 books published around the world on Napoleon and his historical period. Despite such a bibliography, the assessment of Emperor Bonaparte still divides France.

According to a poll published in Le Journal du Dimanche on the occasion of the bicentenary of Napoleon’s coronation in December last year, the Gallic emperor was the second favourite figure of the French (18%), far behind Charles de Gaulle (39%).

The poll revealed that Napoleon remains a great mystery to the French, who see in him many facets: the conqueror of Europe (36%), the father of the Civil Code (30%), the organiser of modern French administration (17%) and the general heir to the French Revolution (11%).

Another survey, carried out at the same time and published by the conservative Le Figaro, showed that 49% of French people considered him “a great political man, ahead of his time and who knew how to apply his ideas” compared to 39% who defined him as “a dictator who used all means to quench his thirst for power”. (EFE)


This post was translated from:

(2005) ‘Historiador sostiene que Napoleón fue precursor de Hitler’, 25 November. Available at: https://www.cooperativa.cl/noticias/sociedad/historia/napoleon/historiador-sostiene-que-napoleon-fue-precursor-de-hitler/2005-11-25/103625.html (Accessed: 28 June 2021).

If you liked this article and found it interesting, you can support us by donating here.
If you liked this article and found it interesting, you can support us by donating here.

Share this article!

1494 Christopher Columbus founded the city of Concepción de la Vega (Dominican Republic), on the island of Hispaniola.
1524 Francisco Hernández de Córdoba founded the city of Granada (Nicaragua), one of the first on the American mainland.
1537 The Spanish captain Alonso de Cáceres founded the city of Comayagua, Honduras, in New Spain, with the name of villa de Sta Mª de la Concepción de Comayagua.
1548 The Spanish captain Alonso de Mercadillo founded the city of Loja, Ecuador, in the viceroyalty of Peru.
1659 The city of Paso del Norte was founded in New Spain and would later be divided into El Paso (United States) and Ciudad Juarez (Mexico).
1709 Jesuit Lucas Caballero founded the mission and town of Concepción (Chiquitos) in curent Bolivia.
1744 The city of Copiapó (Chile) was founded by Governor José Manso de Velasco, with the name of San Francisco de la Selva de Copiapó.

Recommended for you



Share This Story, Choose Your Platform!

Leave A Comment

Go to Top